I think it's a good pick
I also like Indy in that game. It's the only game that looked like a decent bet (except maybe the Giants ML against the Skins).
I can imagine that there are trends going against the Colts here. After winning consistently and dominating the way they've been, they are due for a letdown. I think that they will have a letdown at some point, but it would be against a good team that scores against them and controls the clock. Something that the Patriots, Steelers, and Eagles have a good chance of doing ... but not the Titans.
I have recently only bet on teams that have the ability to "blow out" the other team. The teams with the big-time QBs and skill position players (PHI, IND, SD) along with pretty good defenses have the potential to blow teams out consistently. This seems especially true when these teams are focused or have been clicking and winning consistently.
Something that I have been doing is only betting on teams that I thought had a good chance to cover by at least 7 points. If you can do this consistently, then you won't have to worry about backdoor covers and garbage TDs ruining your otherwise winning bet. After the Eagles' wake-up call in a game against the Steelers, I bet on the Eagles the following 3 weeks going against 3 weak divisional opponents in DAL, NYG and WAS. The Eagles beat the spread by at least 7 points in all 3 games.
Now the Colts appear to be the same type of team. I haven't bet on them at all this year. I was thinking about the Thanksgiving day game, but I didn't pull the trigger. This week, though, I'm definitely pulling the trigger when they face Tennesse. Teams that are going to make the playoffs, are on a roll, and have everything to play for (PHI, IND, SD, ATL, NE, GB, DEN) often blow out teams that aren't going anywhere, have been losing recently, and have upper management problems (MIA, NO, CLE, WAS, ARI, TENN, OAK, SF) in the final few weeks of the regular season.
The Colts' offense is blazing hot and I can't imagine the Titans defense cooling it off. I'll give up 10 points and take the Colts this week.
Other games that look intriguing are:
(I like the team in bold)
Week 14
Oakland @ Atlanta
Miami @ Denver
Philadelphia @ Washington
Week 15
San Diego @ Cleveland
New England @ Miami
Week 16
Denver @ Tennesse
Atlanta @ New Orleans
Week 17
Green Bay @ Chicago
San Francisco @ New England
This methodology has been the most consistently successful for me since I've been betting. I only bet on favorites that I figure will blow out the opposition. If there's not a decent chance of a blowout, I don't risk it.
Anyway, I wrote way more than I ever envisioned, but there it is. Feel free to comment or ask questions...
Scott